Friday, August 1, 2008

Almost 63 years ago, on August 6, 1945 at 8:16 am, an atomic bomb was detonated above Hiroshima, Japan. In that instant, tens of thousands of people were burned, blasted, and crushed to death. Other tens of thousands suffered injuries of every kind or were to die of radiation sickness. The center of the city was flattened, and every part of the city was damaged. Half an hour after the blast, fires set by the thermal pulse and by the collapse of the buildings began to gather into a firestorm that lasted for six hours. Starting about 9 am and lasting until late in the afternoon a "black rain" generated by the bomb fell on the western portions of the city, carrying radioactive fallout from the blast to the ground. For four hours during the middle of the day, a violent wind, created from the strange meteorological conditions produced by the explosion, caused further devastation to the city.

The number of people who were killed immediately or who died of their injuries over the next three months is estimated to be 130,000. Over the next five years it is estimated that another 140,000 died who had suffered burns, nausea, vomiting, bloody discharges, overall weakness, hair loss and disfiguring scar tissue. And decades after the Hiroshima attack, survivors suffer higher rates of cancer than those not exposed to the bombing and many of the approximately 4,000 who were fetuses and are still alive were born mentally retarded and with smaller heads.

A medium-sized nuclear bomb today has an explosive yield of one megaton (a million tons of TNT), or 80 times that of the bomb that destroyed Hiroshima.

As of January 2008, the U.S. stockpile of nuclear weapons contained an estimated 5,400 nuclear warheads, down from a Cold War high of 24,000 in 1987.

You could ask your students:

Consider each of the following statements about U.S. nuclear weapons policy and its current stockpile, what do you think?

1. The U.S. should rely on its current stock of nuclear bombs and not build any additional ones.

2. The U.S. should develop new nuclear bombs as its leaders see a need for them.

3. The U.S. should eliminate nuclear bombs and use only conventional weapons for its defense.

4. The U.S. should cut its nuclear weapons stockpile to a minimum if other nuclear weapons countries are willing to do the same.

5. The U.S. should cut its nuclear weapons stockpile to a minimum no matter what other countries do.

6. The U.S. should maintain its current nuclear weapons stockpile and add to it as necessary.

Each of these statements could provide many different avenues to pursue in considering discussion of the answers and the ramifications that could follow.

3 comments:

Anne said...

Hey Laura,
You're right. That is a little heavier than the typical SMAC, "I was so drunk last night" blog. I love it!

I don't know enough about this topic to have an intelligent conversation, much less with an expert like you, but I would pose to tangentially related questions.
Regarding nuclear power; How much of people's vehement NIMBY attitude toward nuclear power comes from the visceral fear most people have of all things "nuclear"?
And....about a million years ago, when I was in college, there was a guy I heard speak who had written a book called "Brittle Power" all about how our centralized power system makes us so susceptible to terrorism. he was particularly critical of the nuclear power industry....And how do they handle this in France? Lots of nuclear power and no shortage of nuts over there.

--Anne

Jeff Stanzler said...

Laura, I'm moved to pose a related question, and to ask you to have a look at something as it may be of interest.
The question I want to ask you is what you would like to see your students thinking about *as a consequence* of a discussion along the lines that you suggest, and what you would want to provide for them so that they can derive intellectual richness from such a discussion. Having some sense of the kind of thinker you are, my clear sense is that you would eschew any kind of propagandizing...I have no sense that the purpose would be that everyone nod along with this perspective or that. So the purpose of the discussion would be a true intellectual exercise...what would your students need in order to do this, and in order for you to increase the odds that whatever conclusion they reach, they would reach it in such a way that they would have had a useful intellectual experience that involved their asking important questions and seeing the greys along with the black and white.
How would you do it? Especially if you happen to possess a clear point-of-view on the matter. I hope that you will share your thoughts on this in a response.

There's something else. In class on Friday I thought I heard you wondering why it was that teachers were being force-fed computers and technology. To the extent that I fully grasped your question, I think that it's a fair one. Historian Henry Perkinson titled a famous book of his about schooling in America The mperfect Panacea One of his central theses was that the history of schooling in the US is a history of a series of "magic fixes" (panaceas) that reflect our desire to more easily solve the damnably complex job of mass education. Computers have only been one such ostensible panacea, but they are surely a visible one, and a lot of financial resources have been diverted to their purchase that could arguably have gone elsewhere (buying computers is expensive, but is straightforward...speaking effectively to the problem, say, of the achievement gap is a far more complex enterprise).
Now, in both points #1 and #2, matters political (or at least pro-social) and educational are intermixed in challenging ways. In that spirit, I think you will find NYU Professor Clay Shirky's research/thinking to be of interest. He's put together some very interesting observations about how the nature of social action is being changed significantly by the new social technologies. I found this video of his speech before Britain's Royal Society for the encouragement of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce (RSA) to be most intriguing...I'd be interested in reading your thoughts about it if you have the chance to take a look.

Gina said...

To follow up on Jeff’s comment, I agree that it is critical to introduce multiple perspectives into the classroom. This is sometimes challenging when we have positions about which we feel strongly. Often times, many students share the same position, too, so it can be difficult to shed light on alternative points of view. One method for overcoming this is role playing. As an intellectual exercise, a student or group of students may be assigned a perspective to research and defend. Many times the students are curious to know the various viewpoints even if they do not, in the end, agree with them. It deepens their understanding and enables them to defend their positions with greater conviction. I look forward to reading more of your blog!